Table of Contents

About the Author

Lewis Carroll is the pen name of Charles Lutwidge Dodgson, who was born on 27 January 1832 at Daresbury in Cheshire and died on 14 January 1898 at Guildford. He was the son of a clergyman. He was educated at Rugby School and then at Christ Church, Oxford, where he spent the rest of his life, mainly as a lecturer in mathematics. He was a mathematician and logician by profession, an ordained deacon, a keen photographer and a writer of puzzles, and he wrote his children’s books under his pen name.

His most famous work, Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland, was published in 1865, illustrated by Sir John Tenniel, and was an immediate success. It grew from a story he told on a boating trip in 1862 to the three daughters of Henry Liddell, the Dean of Christ Church, one of whom was named Alice. He followed it with Through the Looking-Glass (1871). Both books remain popular with children and with adults.

Background and Context

The extract is a famous scene from Chapter VII, “A Mad Tea-Party”, of the first Alice book. Alice, a sensible and polite Victorian girl, has fallen into a strange underground country, and she meets there a series of eccentric creatures. Here she comes upon three of them at a tea table, viz., the March Hare, the Hatter and a sleeping Dormouse. The Hare and the Hatter take their names from two old English sayings, mad as a March hare and mad as a hatter, and the whole scene is built on the idea of madness.

The book belongs to nonsense literature, a form in which logic, language and common sense are deliberately played with, so that the humour comes from reasoning that seems sound but is absurd. Carroll was a trained logician, and his nonsense is therefore carefully constructed, not random. It is partly a comic reply to the solemn children’s books of Victorian times, which taught lessons and good manners. In Wonderland, manners are made ridiculous, and adults and authority figures are shown as illogical and rude, while the child, Alice, is the sensible one.

Characters

  • Alice is polite, curious, spirited and sensible. She is courteous but not timid: she stands up for herself when she is treated rudely, and she is repeatedly puzzled by the illogical talk around her.
  • The Hatter is eccentric, rude, quick-witted and fond of riddles and puns. He is the most confusing speaker, since his remarks sound meaningful but are not.
  • The March Hare is quarrelsome and defensive, and he is easily beaten in argument by the Hatter’s nonsense.
  • The Dormouse is perpetually sleepy, used as a cushion by the others, and wakes only to agree with whatever has just been said.

Central Theme and Message

The extract has no moral lesson in the Victorian sense, and its purpose is to amuse. But it has several ideas under the humour.

  1. The unreliability of language: words can be turned against their meaning, and a statement that sounds logical may be nonsense.
  2. The absurdity of rigid manners: since the characters accuse one another of rudeness while behaving rudely themselves.
  3. The treatment of time: which is turned into a person who can be offended, and the Hatter’s world, in which time can be controlled, is a comic contrast with the real world in which it cannot.
  4. Contrast between child and adult: Alice, the child, is the one who reasons sensibly and keeps her good manners, and the adults of this strange world are illogical, rude and self-absorbed.
  5. The pleasure of nonsense for its own sake: where an argument leads nowhere and the characters are not troubled by it.

Significance of the Title

The title “A Mad Tea Party” describes the scene exactly. A tea party is the very picture of English politeness and good order, and by calling it “mad” Carroll prepares the reader for the reverse; nobody behaves sensibly, the conversation has no logic, the host’s table has no room and no wine, the riddle has no answer, and the watch tells the wrong thing. The title also refers to the characters, who are mad in the sense of the English sayings from which two of them take their names.

Glossary

Word

Meaning

Indignantly

In an angry way, because of feeling unfairly treated

Civil

Polite and courteous

Curiosity

A strong wish to know or find out something

Raven

A large black bird of the crow family

Writing-desk

A desk or table for writing

Riddle

A puzzling question with a clever or amusing answer

Uneasily

With worry or discomfort

Meekly

Gently, without protest

Grumbled

Complained in a low, discontented voice

Gloomily

In a sad, hopeless manner

Muttered

Spoke in a low, unclear voice, usually when annoyed

Dreadfully

Extremely

Impatiently

With irritation, unable to wait calmly

Sighed

Let out a long breath, showing tiredness, sadness or relief

Wearily

In a tired way

Contemptuously

In a way that shows scorn or lack of respect

Cautiously

Carefully, so as to avoid risk

In a twinkling

In an instant, very quickly

Question-Answers

Q1. Where was the table set? Why did Alice think it was uncomfortable for the Dormouse?

The table was set out under a tree in front of the house. The March Hare and the Hatter were having tea at it, and a Dormouse sat between them, fast asleep. The two of them were using it as a cushion, resting their elbows on it and talking over its head. Alice thought this must be very uncomfortable for the Dormouse, but, since it was asleep, she supposed that it did not mind. Her remark shows her kindness, and it also shows how little regard the other two had for their companion.

Q2. Who were at the Tea Party? What were they doing?

The March Hare, the Hatter and a Dormouse were at the tea party, and Alice joined them. The Hare and the Hatter were having tea, crowded together at one corner of a large table, and the Dormouse, which was asleep between them, served as their cushion. When they saw Alice coming, they cried “No room!”, although there was plenty of space. The Hatter stared at Alice with curiosity and eventually spoke, and the three then argued, asked riddles and talked nonsense about a watch and about Time.

Q3. What did the March Hare offer Alice? What was her reply to it?

The March Hare offered Alice some wine, speaking in an encouraging tone. Alice looked all-round the table but saw nothing on it except tea, and told him that she could not see any wine. He admitted that there was none. Alice then said angrily that it was not very civil of him to offer it. The Hare retorted that it was not very civil of her to sit down without being invited.

Q4. What were Alice’s suggestions as far as having fun was concerned? Were they really fruitful?

Alice’s idea of fun was to take part in the riddles. When the Hatter asked why a raven is like a writing-desk, she thought, “Come, we shall have some fun now!” and said that she believed she could guess it. Later, when no one could answer the riddle, she suggested wearily that they might do something better with their time than waste it on riddles with no answers.

Her suggestions were not fruitful. Her wish to have fun by guessing the riddle came to nothing, because the riddle had no answer, and her suggestion that the others should use their time better was ignored by the Hatter, who turned the talk to Time himself. The fun she looked for was replaced by confusion.

Q5. Why was the watch funny? How did it move?

The watch was funny because it told the day of the month, and not the hour of the day. When Alice said that it was the fourth, the Hatter sighed that it was two days wrong. He said that he had warned the March Hare that butter would not suit the works, and that crumbs must have got in from the bread-knife. The Hare dipped the watch into his tea and could only say that it was the best butter. The Hatter shook the watch and held it to his ear, in the hope of making it work. Alice found it odd that a watch should show the day of the month and not the time, and the Hatter replied that her watch did not tell her the year, which is just as odd. The watch ran wrongly, was two days out, and had been spoiled by butter and crumbs and tea.

Q6. Narrate the story in your own words and explain the title.

Alice comes upon a table under a tree, where the March Hare and the Hatter are having tea with a Dormouse that sleeps between them and serves as their cushion. Although the table is large, they crowd into one corner and cry “No room!” when they see her. Alice sits down angrily, and the Hare offers her wine, but there is none, and the two argue about which of them has been uncivil. The Hatter remarks that her hair needs cutting, and when she says that personal remarks are rude, he asks the riddle about the raven and the writing-desk. Alice thinks it will be fun and offers to guess it, and the Hare tells her to say what she means. She says that she means what she says, and the Hatter shows by comic examples that this is not the same thing. The Hatter then takes out his watch, learns from Alice that it is the fourth, and says that his watch is two days wrong because of the Hare’s butter. He admits that he has no answer to the riddle. Alice tells him that they would do better to use their time than to waste it on riddles, and the Hatter scolds her for speaking of wasting Time, who is a person. When Alice says she has to beat time in music, he says that Time will not stand beating, and that anyone who stayed on good terms with him could make the clock go round at a whisper.

The title is “A Mad Tea Party” because a tea party, the model of polite and orderly behaviour, has here become a scene of complete absurdity. Nobody behaves sensibly, the conversation has no logic, there is no room and no wine, the riddle has no answer, and the watch tells the date and is repaired with butter. The word “mad” describes the characters, who take their names from the sayings mad as a hatter and mad as a March hare, and it describes the party itself.

Q7. Sketch the characters of Alice and the Hatter.

Alice is a well-brought-up, polite and sensible child. She sits down at the table indignantly but remains courteous in her speech, she rebukes the Hatter for making a personal remark, she is eager to join the fun, and she is patient with the nonsense until she becomes weary of it and says plainly that they should do something better with their time. She is curious, spirited and honest, and she is the voice of common sense among the absurd company.

The Hatter is eccentric, rude and sharp. He begins with a personal remark, asks a riddle for which he has no answer, takes everyday expressions literally, and is quarrelsome with the Hare. His talk sounds meaningful but is mostly nonsense, and he enjoys puzzling Alice. Yet he is also witty, and his comic logic and puns, such as the one on “beating time”, show a quick mind. The contrast between the two is the source of much of the scene’s humour.

Q8. Write a short critical appreciation of the extract.

“A Mad Tea Party” is among the best-known scenes of English children’s literature, and its appeal lies in the way it turns reasoning into comedy. Carroll sets a perfectly sensible child among absurd adults, and lets their talk go wrong in every direction: an offer of wine that does not exist, a riddle with no answer, a watch that tells the date, and a quarrel with Time. The dialogue is quick and written in clear, simple language, and the deadpan treatment of absurdity makes the humour sharper. Behind the comedy lies a trained logician’s pleasure in the rules of argument and the tricks of language, and there is also a mild satire of manners and of the adult world. The extract does not teach a lesson, and it is the model of nonsense literature: it is pure play, but deliberate and carefully made. It is also an extract, not the whole chapter, and the Hatter’s later explanation of why the party never ends is not part of it.