Table of Contents
- Meaning of Breach of Contract
- Kinds of Breach of Contract
- Actual or Present Breach of Contract
- Anticipatory Breach of Contract
- Section 39 and Refusal to Perform the Promise in Its Entirety
- Minor Breach is Not Necessarily Repudiation
- Rights of the Promisee in Case of Anticipatory Breach
- Accept the Repudiation
- Keep the Contract Alive
- Case: Hochster v. De La Tour [Right to Sue Immediately]
- Effect of Keeping the Contract Alive
- Case: Avery v. Bowden
- Time for Assessment of Damages in Anticipatory Breach
- Consequences of Breach of Contract
- Distinction Between Actual and Anticipatory Breach
- Important Case Laws
- Conclusion
A contract creates legally enforceable obligations between the parties. Ordinarily, each party is expected to perform the promise undertaken by him in accordance with the terms of the contract. Where a party fails to perform the obligation imposed upon him, refuses to perform it, or by his own conduct makes performance impossible, a breach of contract is said to have occurred.
Breach of contract is therefore different from mere non-performance arising from a legally recognised discharge of the contract. If a party is excused from performance because of a valid ground such as supervening impossibility under Section 56, there may be no breach. Breach presupposes a failure or refusal to perform an obligation which remains legally binding.
The law relating to breach is important because breach gives rise to legal consequences and remedies in favour of the aggrieved party. The principal remedy for breach is compensation or damages, which is dealt with principally by Sections 73 and 74 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872. Other remedies, such as specific performance, injunction and rescission, are governed substantially by the Specific Relief Act, 1963.
Breach of contract may broadly be classified into:
- Actual or present breach of contract; and
- Anticipatory breach of contract.
Meaning of Breach of Contract
A breach of contract occurs when a party who is under a contractual obligation:
- fails to perform his promise when performance is due;
- refuses to perform his contractual obligation;
- expressly repudiates the contract; or
- by his own act makes himself incapable of performing the contract.
Thus, breach may consist either of non-performance or repudiation of the contractual obligation.
For example, A agrees to deliver 100 bags of sugar to B on 1 January. If A fails to deliver the goods on that date without lawful justification, A commits an actual breach of contract. Similarly, if A informs B before 1 January that he will not deliver the goods at all, A commits an anticipatory breach.
It is important, however, to distinguish a breach which merely gives rise to a claim for compensation from a breach which entitles the other party to terminate the contract. Every breach does not necessarily give the innocent party a right to put an end to the entire contractual relationship. The consequences depend upon the nature of the contractual obligation and the applicable law.
Kinds of Breach of Contract
Breach of contract is principally of two kinds:
- Actual or present breach, and
- Anticipatory breach.
Actual or Present Breach of Contract
An actual breach occurs when the time for performance has arrived and a party fails or refuses to perform his contractual obligation. It may occur in two situations:
a) Breach on the date fixed for performance
Where a party is required to perform his promise on a particular date but fails or refuses to do so, there is an actual breach at the time when performance becomes due.
- Example: A agrees to deliver 100 bags of sugar to B on 1 January. A does not deliver the goods on 1 January. A has committed an actual breach of contract.
The essential feature is that the contractual obligation has already become due for performance.
b) Breach during the performance of the contract
Actual breach may also occur in the course of performance where the contract requires continuing or successive performance and one party fails or refuses to perform an obligation.
- For example, A agrees to supply goods to B in several instalments over a period of six months. If A refuses to make further deliveries in circumstances amounting to breach, an actual breach may arise during the subsistence of the contract.
The question whether such a breach entitles the other party to terminate the whole contract depends upon the nature and effect of the breach. A minor irregularity or isolated default should not automatically be treated as a repudiation of the entire contract.
Anticipatory Breach of Contract
An anticipatory breach occurs when a party repudiates or disables himself from performing the contract before the date fixed for performance. The breach is therefore “anticipatory” because the time for performance has not yet arrived.
Section 39 of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 specifically deals with refusal to perform a promise in its entirety. It provides, in substance, that where a party to a contract:
- refuses to perform his promise in its entirety, or
- disables himself from performing his promise in its entirety,
the promisee may put an end to the contract, unless he has, by words or conduct, signified his acquiescence in its continuance.
Anticipatory breach may occur in two ways:
- Expressly, through words or communication; or
- Impliedly, through conduct which makes it clear that the party will not perform the contract.
Express Anticipatory Breach
An express anticipatory breach occurs when the promisor clearly communicates, before the due date, that he will not perform his contractual obligation.
- For example, A agrees on 15 July to supply 10 bales of cotton to B on 14 August. On 30 July, A informs B that he will not supply the cotton on 14 August. A has expressly repudiated the contract.
The communication must be sufficiently clear to demonstrate an intention not to perform the contractual obligation.
Anticipatory Breach by Conduct (Implied)
Repudiation need not always be expressed in words. A party may, by his conduct, place himself in a position where he cannot perform the contract.
- For example, A agrees to sell a particular horse to B on 10 August. Before that date, A sells the same horse to C. A has, by his conduct, disabled himself from performing his promise to B.
Such conduct may constitute an anticipatory breach.
Section 39 and Refusal to Perform the Promise in Its Entirety
Section 39 is particularly important because it does not treat every minor default as a repudiation of the entire contract. The provision is concerned with a refusal to perform, or disabling oneself from performing, the promise in its entirety. The expression is significant. A mere failure in relation to one minor or subsidiary aspect of a contract will not necessarily amount to repudiation of the entire contractual obligation.
Illustration
Suppose A enters into a contract involving several deliveries of goods. If one delivery contains a relatively minor defect, it does not automatically follow that A has repudiated the entire contract. The court must consider the contractual obligation as a whole and the effect of the breach.
This principle prevents parties from treating every technical or insignificant default as a justification for terminating an entire contractual relationship.
Minor Breach is Not Necessarily Repudiation
The law distinguishes between a breach of an obligation and a repudiation of the entire contract. A minor irregularity in performance should not ordinarily be treated as an intention to abandon the contract altogether. The court examines the substance and effect of the conduct rather than merely its form.
In Freeth v. Burr, the court emphasised the importance of determining whether the conduct of the party demonstrated an intention to abandon and altogether refuse performance of the contract.
Similarly, in Rash Behary Saha v. N. Gopal Nundy, failure to take delivery under one contract did not, in the circumstances, amount to a refusal to perform the contractual obligations in their entirety so as to entitle the other party to rescind the contracts.
Likewise, in Sooltan Chand v. Schiller, withholding part payment pursuant to a bona fide claim was not treated as a refusal to perform the contract in its entirety.
The question is not simply whether some breach has occurred. The court must determine whether the breach is of such a character that it amounts to a refusal to perform the contract in its entirety or otherwise justifies termination.
Rights of the Promisee in Case of Anticipatory Breach
When one party commits an anticipatory breach, the innocent party is generally faced with an election. The promisee may:
- Accept the repudiation and treat the contract as terminated, or
- Refuse to accept the repudiation and keep the contract alive, subject to the legal consequences of that election.
This principle is embodied in Section 39.
Accept the Repudiation
The innocent party may accept the repudiation and treat the contract as at an end. He may then bring an action for the consequences of the breach without waiting until the date originally fixed for performance.
- For example, A agrees to supply goods to B on 1 January. On 1 December, A unequivocally informs B that he will not supply the goods. B may accept A’s repudiation and take appropriate legal action rather than waiting until 1 January.
This rule prevents the innocent party from being compelled to wait until the contractual date when the other party has already made it clear that performance will not occur.
Keep the Contract Alive
Instead of accepting the repudiation, the promisee may elect to treat the contract as continuing and wait until the date fixed for performance. However, this election carries an important risk.
Once the promisee elects to keep the contract alive, the contract continues to operate for the benefit and detriment of both parties. The promisor is not necessarily deprived of the opportunity to perform merely because he had previously repudiated the contract. Moreover, a supervening event may subsequently discharge the contract under the doctrine of frustration or impossibility. In such a case, the innocent party may lose the opportunity to claim damages for the original anticipatory repudiation. This principle is illustrated by Avery v. Bowden.
Case: Hochster v. De La Tour [Right to Sue Immediately]
The classic English decision in Hochster v. De La Tour illustrates the principle of anticipatory breach.
In this case, A engaged B as a courier for a European tour which was to begin on 1 June. Before the commencement of the tour, A informed B that his services would not be required. B brought an action before the date on which he was required to begin work. The court held that B was entitled to sue immediately upon the repudiation.
Thus, where one party, before the due date of performance, unequivocally refuses to perform his contractual obligation, the innocent party need not necessarily wait until the date fixed for performance before seeking a remedy.
Effect of Keeping the Contract Alive
If the promisee does not accept the repudiation, the contract continues. The promisor may subsequently reconsider his position and perform his promise. More importantly, an event occurring after the repudiation may make performance impossible or unlawful.
Case: Avery v. Bowden
A chartered B’s ship at a Russian port and undertook to provide cargo within a specified period. A failed to provide the cargo and refused to do so. B nevertheless kept the contract alive. Before the period expired, war broke out between England and Russia, making performance unlawful.
The court held, in effect, that the subsequent supervening event discharged the contract. Because the contract had been kept alive rather than terminated upon the original repudiation, the later frustration affected the parties’ rights.
Thus, the innocent party who chooses to keep an anticipatorily repudiated contract alive assumes the risk of subsequent events that may discharge the contract. Therefore, keeping the contract alive is not necessarily advantageous in every case.
Time for Assessment of Damages in Anticipatory Breach
Where an anticipatory breach is accepted and the contract is treated as terminated, the question arises as to the appropriate time for assessing damages. The general principle is that the loss is ordinarily assessed with reference to the position resulting from the breach and the time at which the innocent party’s cause of action arises. In cases of anticipatory breach, the date of acceptance of repudiation can therefore be highly significant. Where, however, the promisee elects to keep the contract alive until the date fixed for performance, the consequences may be assessed with reference to the position existing at the time performance was due, subject to the applicable principles governing damages. The precise measure of damages is governed principally by Section 73, including its rules concerning causation, reasonable foreseeability and mitigation.
Consequences of Breach of Contract
The principal legal consequence of breach is that the innocent party may obtain a remedy against the party in breach.
The most important remedy is compensation by way of damages. Section 73 of the Indian Contract Act lays down the general principle for compensation for loss or damage caused by breach of contract, while Section 74 deals with stipulated sums and penalties. Depending upon the nature of the contract and the circumstances, the law may also permit other remedies, particularly under the Specific Relief Act, 1963.
The major consequences may therefore be stated as follows:
- Right to claim compensation - The injured party may claim compensation for loss or damage legally caused by the breach, subject to the limitations imposed by law.
- Right to terminate in appropriate cases - Where the breach amounts to repudiation or falls within a situation in which the law permits termination, the innocent party may put an end to the contractual relationship. However, not every breach entitles the aggrieved party to terminate the entire contract.
- Right to other appropriate contractual remedies - Depending on the nature of the obligation, the aggrieved party may seek remedies such as specific performance or injunction where the requirements of the Specific Relief Act are satisfied.
- Duty to mitigate loss - A person claiming compensation cannot ordinarily recover loss which he could reasonably have avoided. The injured party is expected to take reasonable steps to minimise the consequences of the breach. The principle is closely connected with the assessment of damages under Section 73.
Distinction Between Actual and Anticipatory Breach
|
Basis |
Actual Breach |
Anticipatory Breach |
|
Time |
Occurs when performance is due or during performance. |
Occurs before the date fixed for performance. |
|
Nature |
Actual failure or refusal to perform. |
Advance repudiation or disabling oneself from performing. |
|
Section |
Governed by general provisions concerning breach and remedies. |
Specifically addressed by Section 39. |
|
Example |
A fails to deliver goods on the agreed date. |
A informs B beforehand that he will not deliver the goods. |
|
Choice available to Innocent Party |
Depends upon nature of breach and contractual rights. |
May accept repudiation or, subject to Section 39, elect to continue the contract. |
|
Risk of Subsequent Frustration |
Ordinarily not an issue in the same manner. |
Particularly important where the innocent party keeps the contract alive. |
Important Case Laws
- Hochster v. De La Tour (1853) - An innocent party may sue upon an anticipatory repudiation without necessarily waiting until the contractual date of performance.
- Avery v. Bowden (1855) - Where the innocent party elects to keep an anticipatorily repudiated contract alive, a subsequent supervening event may discharge the contract and affect the right to damages.
- Frost v. Knight (1872) - A clear anticipatory repudiation may give rise to an immediate cause of action before the contractual date of performance.
- Freeth v. Burr (1874) - A minor or disputed default does not automatically amount to repudiation. The court considers whether the conduct demonstrates an intention to abandon the contract.
- Sooltan Chand v. Schiller - Withholding part payment pursuant to a bona fide claim was not, in the circumstances, a refusal to perform the contract in its entirety.
- Rash Behary Saha v. N. Gopal Nundy - Failure relating to one transaction or part of contractual performance does not necessarily constitute refusal to perform the contract in its entirety under Section 39.
Conclusion
Breach of contract represents the failure of a party to fulfil a contractual obligation which the law continues to require him to perform. It may take place either when performance becomes due or, in the case of anticipatory breach, before the due date.
The distinction between actual and anticipatory breach is particularly significant. Section 39 gives the promisee an important choice in cases of anticipatory repudiation; he may treat the contract as terminated or, subject to the statutory rule, decide to continue it. The latter course may expose him to the consequences of subsequent events, including frustration of the contract.
At the same time, the law does not permit every minor default to be treated as repudiation of the entire contract. The character and effect of the breach must be examined in the context of the contractual obligation as a whole.
The ultimate purpose of the law relating to breach is to provide an appropriate remedy to the injured party. Damages under Sections 73 and 74 form the central monetary remedy, and their proper determination requires an understanding of the measure of damages, causation, mitigation and the rule of remoteness.